A figure for the weight of a Japanese sword cannot be compared unless you know what was included in the weighing. Whether it is the blade alone or the blade housed in a shirasaya or koshirae, the number changes even for the same sword. The basic approach is first to confirm what was weighed, and then to read the figure alongside the blade length.
Three entries from the Nagoya Touken Museum's table
The Nagoya Touken World Museum commentary page includes a table giving the weights and blade lengths of swords it features. We have selected just three entries from that table.
| Work | Weight | Blade length |
|---|---|---|
| Katana, orikaeshi-mei: Bishū Osafune-jū Motoshige | 658g | 68.3cm |
| Katana, mei: Rakuyō Ichijō Horikawa-jū Fujiwara Kunihiro, Keichō kanoto-i hachigatsu-bi | 724g | 68.1cm |
| Katana, mei: Suishinshi Masahide, Tenmei gonen nigatsu-bi, hori dōsaku | 928g | 69.4cm |
These three entries are examples featured by the museum. They are not figures representing an average or standard for Japanese swords as a whole. In addition, whether accessories were included when the swords were weighed could not be determined from what the source states. Please treat the measurement conditions as unknown, and read the figures without assuming that they are the weight of the blade alone.
A 270 g spread within a 1.3 cm difference in blade length
The blade lengths of the three entries range from 68.1 cm to 69.4 cm, a maximum difference of 1.3 cm. The weights range from 658 g to 928 g, a spread of 270 g. At least within the scope of this table, blades of similar length are not necessarily of similar weight.
The reason for the difference cannot be read from the table. Differences in the width or thickness of the blade, and differences in what was included in the weighing, are both conceivable possibilities. However, there is nothing to show which of them applies. It is safest to treat blade length and weight as values to be checked separately.
Conditions for comparing weight
What tends to happen when comparing numbers is that values measured under different conditions end up side by side in the same table. Suppose, for example, that the weight given for sword A is with the blade housed in its koshirae, while the weight given for sword B does not state what was weighed. In that case, looking at which number is larger will not tell you which blade is heavier.
The same applies to length: check the measurement's endpoints and whether the same standard is used. For an explanation of length, see Types and Lengths.
What to confirm with the seller
If you are considering a purchase and want to use weight as one of the factors in your decision, asking the seller the following three questions will give you a basis for comparison with other candidates.
- What was included in the weighing for the stated weight
- Whether the figure includes a scabbard and, if so, whether it is a shirasaya or a koshirae
- What accessories there are
If no weight is recorded, include the same three points when requesting it so that the measurement conditions are clear. Weight contributes to the impression in hand, but does not determine assessment or price by itself. Other checks are summarized in Checks before Purchase.